Live Yum Brands Vote →
← Back to Current Poll
Closed Voting

Diamond or Dud?

The weekly showdown where investors decide if controversial stocks are hidden gems or complete trash

⚡ A few minutes a week to sharpen your market knowledge.

Diamond or Dud is for entertainment purposes only. AssetRoom does not provide financial advice. Figures collected prior to poll publication.
Poll Ran
Dec 05 – Dec 12, 2025
Market Cap
$423B
Est. Q4 Revenue
$1.34B
Q3 2025 Revenue
$1.18B
Net Dollar Retention
134%

What's your verdict on PLTR?

Here's how the community voted

14%
86%
💎 Diamond 💩 Dud
💎
Diamond Case
💩
Dud Case
💎
Diamond Case
💩
Dud Case

Discussion

This poll has closed. New comments cannot be added.

@nicholasjmills · 8 months ago (6 points)

While there are indeed three factors that could lead to further gains for Palantir in 2026 (strong defence spending; AI investment remaining high; analyst consensus on the bull market for stocks continuing)… the valuation remains very disconnected from fundamentals even with the benefit of these tailwinds. The risks associated to the Company (pullback from AI euphoria, revenue concentration, competition from other big tech companies) lead to too much downside risk for me. The markets are pricing in flawless execution in a best-case scenario, at the current valuation.

👍 6 upvotes
@m15o · 8 months ago (1 point)

I agree with the revenue concentration part. I'd stay away from investing in a company so in geopolitical activities. Also that $950M shares sold by insiders over the last year vs $1 doesn't bring a lot of confidence...

👍 1 upvote
@glk_01 · 8 months ago (1 point)

Perfectly sums it up in my opinion. Flawless execution can’t continue forever, and the fundamentals do not seem to be there.

👍 1 upvote
@sire_frugalman · 8 months ago (5 points)

CEO Alex Karp has described himself as "geographically monogomous". I'm getting Adam Neumann of WeWork vibes. Hard to see Palantir going quite the same way but no way 350x earnings holds up.

👍 5 upvotes
@cattoginger · 8 months ago (1 point)

I could see them bending that to supporting any ally, similar to what other defense contractors (CAE, etc.) do. But still, it's hard to justify the current valuation...

👍 1 upvote
@sire_frugalman · 8 months ago (1 point)

Quite, althoguh I'm not sure that was what he was referring to with his monogamy!

👍 1 upvote
@cattoginger · 8 months ago (3 points)

There have been a lot of great innovations in history, and you can pay almost any multiple in some cases, but Palantir is so far off the normal valuation levels that you need something beyond heroic to justify fundamentally valued ownership. You need this company to grow so much (as it sells at 100x TTM revenue), and continue to generate great margins, to justify it from a valuation perspective. This comes from a guy who prefers 10x P/E as a baseline, so what do I know?

Management could probably go on an acquisition spree with such a high share price to use as their currency.

👍 3 upvotes
@cattoginger · 8 months ago (1 point)

Let me just add to this. Innovations today, by their nature, have to be less impactful than past innovations such as railroads or electricity. They enabled so much (such as the use of previously unproductive land due to transportation costs) and yet along the way, many went through bankruptcy - even the ones that succeeded and are still around today. Betting with such a high valuation level doesn't usually end well.

👍 1 upvote
@stonemonkeys · 8 months ago (3 points)

The insider trading says it all!

👍 3 upvotes
@DiamondHandsMcgee · 8 months ago (2 points)

I'd be selling my stock too if my CEO was spending all his time waving a silly little sword around the office, definite dud

👍 2 upvotes
💬 10 comments

Share your vote. See who agrees.

$PLTR - Diamond or Dud?

💎 🟦⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜ 14%
💩 🟫🟫🟫🟫🟫🟫🟫🟫🟫⬜ 86%

https://www.assetroom.net/p/6qVhOr
Or share on