Live CrowdStrike Holdings, Inc. Vote →
← Back to Current Poll
Closed Voting

Diamond or Dud?

The weekly showdown where investors decide if controversial stocks are hidden gems or complete trash

⚡ A few minutes a week to sharpen your market knowledge.

Diamond or Dud is for entertainment purposes only. AssetRoom does not provide financial advice. Figures collected prior to poll publication.
💡
Why we're voting on SMCI this week

Super Micro posted $60 billion in new orders last quarter - roughly five times its quarterly revenue run rate. The stock jumped more than 20% this week after the company also nearly doubled gross margin guidance to 15-17%, up from prior guidance of 8.2-8.4% for the same quarter. A deal to co-build a gigawatt-scale AI data center with SpaceX and xAI added fuel.

The problem is everything else. An SVP was indicted in March for allegedly smuggling $2.5 billion in restricted AI servers to China. Ernst & Young resigned as auditor in 2024, citing concerns about management’s integrity. The SEC has issued two subpoenas. The stock is still down 74% from its 2024 high despite this week’s rally.

Super Micro is the cheapest way to play AI infrastructure at ~9x forward earnings. It’s also the only AI stock where a board member faces up to 20 years in federal prison.

Poll Ran
Jul 24 – Jul 31, 2026
Q4 Orders
$60B+
Market Cap
~$20B
Forward P/E
~9x
Gross Margin
15-17%

What's your verdict on SMCI?

Here's how the community voted

100%
💎 Diamond 💩 Dud
💎
Diamond Case
  • AI data center spending is accelerating and Super Micro is at the center. Revenue grew 123% year-over-year in Q3, with full-year guidance near $40 billion. The $60 billion in Q4 orders represents roughly three times FY2025 annual revenue in forward visibility. SpaceX/xAI tapped Super Micro to co-build a gigawatt-scale data center in under a year.

  • Gross margins nearly doubled from 6.3% to a guided 15-17% in two quarters as the mix shifted toward liquid cooling and complete rack solutions. Management says it holds 70-80% of the liquid-cooled AI server market and was among the first to ship NVIDIA’s Blackwell GB200 and GB300 platforms.

  • At roughly 9x forward earnings and 0.5x sales, Super Micro is the cheapest AI infrastructure play by a wide margin. Dell trades at roughly 23x forward with slower revenue growth. Analysts have an average price target near $40, implying about 30% upside, and Needham raised its target to $46 after the order disclosure.

💩
Dud Case
  • Super Micro was delisted for accounting violations in 2018 and nearly got delisted again in 2024 after Ernst & Young resigned as auditor, citing integrity concerns. The SEC has issued two subpoenas, the DOJ is investigating, and SVP Wally Liaw was indicted in March for smuggling $2.5 billion in restricted AI servers to China.

  • The $60 billion in orders include items that “may not constitute firm commitments” and “may be subject to cancellation.” Super Micro burned $7.56 billion in operating cash in nine months with $8.8 billion in debt against $1.3 billion in cash. It raised $10 billion in equity and convertible debt this year to fund a backlog that may not convert.

  • Dell’s AI server revenue grew 757% last quarter with a $51 billion backlog in the same range as Super Micro’s. NVIDIA is preparing to sell pre-assembled Vera Rubin compute trays directly, compressing the OEM role. And 63% of Q2 revenue came from a single unnamed customer.

💎
Diamond Case
  • AI data center spending is accelerating and Super Micro is at the center. Revenue grew 123% year-over-year in Q3, with full-year guidance near $40 billion. The $60 billion in Q4 orders represents roughly three times FY2025 annual revenue in forward visibility. SpaceX/xAI tapped Super Micro to co-build a gigawatt-scale data center in under a year.

  • Gross margins nearly doubled from 6.3% to a guided 15-17% in two quarters as the mix shifted toward liquid cooling and complete rack solutions. Management says it holds 70-80% of the liquid-cooled AI server market and was among the first to ship NVIDIA’s Blackwell GB200 and GB300 platforms.

  • At roughly 9x forward earnings and 0.5x sales, Super Micro is the cheapest AI infrastructure play by a wide margin. Dell trades at roughly 23x forward with slower revenue growth. Analysts have an average price target near $40, implying about 30% upside, and Needham raised its target to $46 after the order disclosure.

💩
Dud Case
  • Super Micro was delisted for accounting violations in 2018 and nearly got delisted again in 2024 after Ernst & Young resigned as auditor, citing integrity concerns. The SEC has issued two subpoenas, the DOJ is investigating, and SVP Wally Liaw was indicted in March for smuggling $2.5 billion in restricted AI servers to China.

  • The $60 billion in orders include items that “may not constitute firm commitments” and “may be subject to cancellation.” Super Micro burned $7.56 billion in operating cash in nine months with $8.8 billion in debt against $1.3 billion in cash. It raised $10 billion in equity and convertible debt this year to fund a backlog that may not convert.

  • Dell’s AI server revenue grew 757% last quarter with a $51 billion backlog in the same range as Super Micro’s. NVIDIA is preparing to sell pre-assembled Vera Rubin compute trays directly, compressing the OEM role. And 63% of Q2 revenue came from a single unnamed customer.

Discussion

This poll has closed. New comments cannot be added.

💬 Be first to comment

Share your vote. See who agrees.

$SMCI - Diamond or Dud?

💎 🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦🟦 100%
💩 ⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜ 0%

https://www.assetroom.net/p/M3NhNr
Or share on